Tag Archives: Passwords

Acceptance of FIDO 2.0 Specifications by the W3C accelerates the movement to end passwords


What if we could eliminate, or at least significantly mitigate the risk of passwords? On February 17, 2016, the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) announced that the creation of the Web Authentication Working Group to move the world closer to this goal. The mission of the group is to define a client-side API that provides strong authentication functionality to Web Applications. The group’s technical work will be accelerated by the acceptance of the FIDO 2.0 Web APIs. This specification, whose co- authors include PayPal’s Hubert Le Van Gong and Jeff Hodges, help simplify and improve the security of authentication.  As the steward for the Web platform, the W3C is uniquely positioned to focus the attention of Web infrastructure providers and developers on the shortcomings of passwords and the necessity of their replacement.

The FIDO2.0 protocol employs public key cryptography, relying on users’ devices to generate key pairs during a registration process. The user’s device retains the generated private key and delivers the public key to the service provider. The service provider retains this key, associates it with a user’s account, and when a login request is received, issues a challenge that must be signed by the private key holder as a response.

When challenged, the FIDO implementation stack signals the user to authenticate using the mechanism employed at registration time. This might be via PIN, biometric reader, or an alternative modality. A local comparison of the current authentication request is made to the stored registration value. A successful match unlocks the associated private key; the challenge is signed and returned to the service provider.

This approach dramatically alters the economics of attacks on service providers and their password stores. For each service provider that a user interacts with, a unique private/public key pair is generated. Not only does this ensure that service providers are unable to use protocol artifacts to collude in user-unwanted ways, it renders the public key store of little to no value to fraudsters. Attacks at scale through exfiltration of passwords are no longer a viable means of generating revenue – the ultimate goal of fraudsters.

Early version of the FIDO protocols, UAF and U2F, were developed with deployments by PayPal and others. Much has been learned through the process with the Fido 2.0 specifications designed to bring together the best features of U2F and UAF. With the contribution of the Fido 2.0 APIs to the W3C, they will be sedimented into the Web Platform enabling authoring tools, hosting providers, and others to interoperate will a broad range of devices that will support the Fido 2.0 protocols. 

At PayPal, we are committed to a more secure and privacy-respecting web experience for all internet users. We realize that an easy-to-use, secure, and privacy-respecting means of authentication benefits everyone and having the same protections regardless of the site enhances the overall security of the Web. We look forward to actively participating in the W3C Web Authentication Working Group to continue our pursuit of ubiquitous, simple, secure, and privacy-respecting authentication on the Web.